Thomson logo Thomson Tax & Accounting Insight banner   Thomson Tax & Accounting Insight banner

 

Issue 162, 9 November 2007

Welcome %%firstname%%, to the latest issue of Thomson's Tax & Accounting Insight, your free news service for tax and accounting professionals.

Tax & Accounting Insight is the easy way to keep up with the latest developments in your industry. Watch your inbox for your fortnightly issue of this free, informative service from Thomson.

Articles in this edition include:

Editorial Enquiries:
Tel: 1300 304 197
LRA.Service@thomson.com

Copyright:
Thomson Legal & Regulatory Limited
ABN 64 058 914 668
100 Harris Street
Pyrmont NSW 2009
All rights reserved.

To subscribe, please click here.

To unsubscribe, please reply to this email with Unsubscribe in the heading.

Disclaimer:
The information contained in this bulletin neither represents nor is intended to be legal or professional advice. While every care has been taken in its preparation, no person should act specifically on the basis of the material contained herein. If expert assistance is required, competent professional advice should be obtained.

Privacy Policy

Tax Office on managing the tax risks in sports industry

The Tax Office has recently advised of its concerns in relation to the sports industry. In a speech to the ANZSLA Conference 2007, Tax Office Second Commissioner Jennie Granger noted the expanding range of tax obligations of sports clubs and associations. In particular, Ms Granger highlighted the Tax Office's concerns in relation to football clubs and player remuneration packages. Ms Granger said a Tax Office scoping project of football clubs is underway to obtain an understanding of the compliance issues.

Other concerns raised by Ms Granger included players and their tax obligations. Ms Granger said the Tax Office is reviewing lodgment of over 2,000 players, officials and administrators and has actioned around 300 outstanding returns. Further, Ms Granger said the Tax Office is also looking at major sporting events (including international events). She said the Tax Office is working with international team managers and their Australian-based tax advisers. To date, Ms Granger said the Tax Office has been involved with golf, tennis and cricket events.

This article appeared in Thomson's daily Latest Tax News (Monday 5th November). With tax fast-moving and ever changing - EVERY DAY, practitioners rely on Thomson's daily Latest Tax News for quick, accurate, comprehensive information - no compromises. When you need to know what's new in tax and related news every day, there's only one place to look - LTN. To find out more, click here.

Return to TOP

Whether family trust distribution tax payable on trust distributions

Q. We have a discretionary trust that has only two beneficiaries. They are an individual and a well-known public Australian university. Distributions to the university have to be used for scholarships for undergraduate students. On the death of the individual beneficiary, all distributions will be made to the university. The trust has made a family trust election. Is family trust distribution tax payable in respect of the distributions to the university?

A. Section 271-15 in Schedule 2F to ITAA 1936 provides that family trust distribution tax is payable if, at any time while a family trust election is in force (including a time before it was made), the trust confers a present entitlement to, or distributes, income or capital of the trust upon or to a person who is not the individual specified in the family trust election nor a member of that individual's family group. The question, therefore, is whether the university is a member of the relevant individual's family group. (Note that since the term 'person' is defined in section 6(1) of ITAA 1936 to include a company and a 'company' is defined in s 995-1 of  ITAA 1997 to include a 'body corporate', the university is a 'person'.)

The 'family group' includes certain tax-exempt entities specified in various provisions of ITAA 1997 (including sections 50-5, 50-10 and 50-20) or certain entities mentioned in the table in section 30-15 of ITAA 1997 to which a tax-deductible gift may be given: see section 272-90(6), (7) in Schedule 2F. If the university qualifies as one of those bodies, it will be part of the family group and family trust distribution tax will not be payable in respect of any distributions to the university.

One of the types of exempt entity listed in section 50-5 is a public educational institution, which 'has a physical presence in Australia and, to that extent, incurs its expenditure and pursues its objectives principally in Australia': see section 50-55. If the university in this case is a 'public educational institution', it will be tax-exempt under section 50-5 and therefore part of the relevant 'family group' for the purposes of the family trust rules in Schedule 2F.

What is a 'public educational institution' in terms of section 50-5? The term is not defined in ITAA 1997 (or ITAA 1936) and there is very little jurisprudence on the meaning of the term. However, it is inconceivable that an Australian university open to all students (who satisfy the entrance requirements) is not a public educational institution. This is supported by Windeyer J's observation in Incorporated Council of Law Reporting (Queensland) v. FCT (1971) 2 ATR 515 (at 523) that a 'public educational institution is generally understood to be an establishment, in which instruction is given in some branch of knowledge or in some art or science, the pupils being drawn from the public generally or from some substantial and significant section of the public'.

In conclusion, as the university is a public educational institution that is exempt from income tax under section 50-5 of the ITAA 1997, it is taken to be part of the relevant family group by virtue of section 272-90(7) in Schedule 2F and therefore distributions from the trust to the university are not subject to family distribution tax.

This issue appeared recently in Thomson Tax Q&A. Thomson Tax Q&A is issues-based and uses actual scenarios confronted in practice to help you understand how developments affect your client's tax position. New Q&As are added regularly and the answers provided online are updated to take into account tax changes that impact on the issues raised. It therefore provides an up-to-date database of real solutions to actual tax issues facing tax advisers in practice. To obtain more information, or to subscribe, simply contact your nearest Thomson representative or call 1300 304 197.

Return to TOP

Garnishee notice issued to solicitors held void CTH 2/11/2007

Bruton Holdings Pty Limited (in liq) v. FCT

The Federal Court has held that a notice issued by the Commissioner pursuant to section 260-5 of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (a 'garnishee' or 'third party' notice) to solicitors for a corporate taxpayer, in relation to a $7.7 million tax debt of the taxpayer, was void under section 500(1) of the Corporations Act 2001. The notice related to over $400,000 held by the solicitors in trust for the taxpayer 'on account of costs and disbursements'. The Court agreed with the taxpayer's argument that the notice was an 'attachment ... put in force against the property of the company after the passing of the resolution for voluntary winding up' for the purposes of section 500(1) and was therefore void. (In the matter of Bruton Holdings Pty Limited (in liq) v. FCT [2007] FCA 1643, Federal Court, Allsop J, 2 November 2007.)

The article comes from A-Z of Trusts, fortnightly email news alert (Wednesday, 7 November 2007). A-Z of Trusts is a one-stop resource authored by field experts from Deacons law firm, giving you current, detailed information and practical assistance on modern trust planning concepts. To find out more, click here.

Return to TOP

Thomson Tools

Stay on top of your compliance obligations with these official ASIC publications

ASIC Digest

Always have the very latest compliance information at your fingertips with the ASIC Digest! Comprising seven volumes with a regular update service, you'll get a first-hand understanding of ASIC policies and activities, in a form that's been designed for maximum practicality and usability to save you time and resources.

ASIC Forms

This is your system for filling in and managing commonly lodged ASIC forms direct from your computer. Mistakes are quickly remedied, client or company information can be easily updated and you can use the same template again and again.

ASIC Working Guide for Accountants

Gain an understanding of key issues including accounts and audit relief, financial reporting requirements, insolvency, document lodgment, takeovers, share transactions, audit notification, and auditor competency and qualification with this fully authorised abridged version of the ASIC Digest (the manual used by ASIC employees) for accountants.

ASIC Working Guide for Company Directors

Stay on top of your corporate governance obligations with essential ASIC information straight from the regulator. Quickly locate relevant information, including ASIC Policy Statements, Practice Notes, Class Orders, media and information releases and more affecting your role. Save time and help reduce the risk of penalties by gaining a better understanding of the corporate regulatory environment and your responsibilities within it.

ASIC Financial Services Policy Handbook

This essential reference tool from ASIC shows you how to fulfil your compliance obligations and acquire and maintain an Australian Financial Services Licence.

Gain quick access to key compliance information to help you understand advising and dealing, financial requirements, dispute resolution, training of advisers, product disclosure, financial markets and relief from certain parts of the law.

ASIC Managed Investments Handbook

The ASIC Managed Investments Handbook is an essential tool for all who deal with managed investment schemes as it helps you stay on top of your compliance obligations, save time and comply with ASIC guidelines faster, easier and more effectively.

This handbook helps investment professionals keep up-to-date with ASIC licensing requirements and scheme compliance, product disclosure requirements, and the relief available for managed investment scheme operators. You'll also have access to regularly updated executive summaries, class orders, pro-formas, media releases, reports and speeches and the ASIC Licensing Kit and guides.

Return to TOP